TaxCarbon
Offsetting

Carbon Offsetting in the UK: Does It Actually Work?

Offsetting is the idea that you can pay for a tonne of carbon to be removed or avoided somewhere else to balance a tonne you emit. Done well, it funds real tree planting and peat restoration in the UK. Done badly, it has let companies claim to be carbon neutral while changing nothing. This guide explains how it works, what separates a credible credit from a worthless one, and the rules now governing what you can claim.

How offsetting works

A carbon credit represents one tonne of CO2 equivalent that a project claims to have removed from the atmosphere or prevented from entering it. The project is validated against a standard, the credits are issued on a registry, a buyer purchases them, and then retires them so that no one else can use the same tonne. The buyer can then say they have offset a tonne of their own emissions.

There are two very different kinds of credit. Removal credits pay for carbon to be physically taken out of the air: trees growing, peat re-wetting, or engineered capture and storage. Avoidance credits pay for emissions that would otherwise have happened not to happen: a forest not being cut down, a coal plant not being built, a cookstove replaced. Avoidance credits are far more common and far cheaper, and they are where almost all of the controversy lies, because proving what would otherwise have happened is inherently uncertain.

This is the voluntary carbon market. It is separate from compliance markets like the UK Emissions Trading Scheme, where the government sets a cap and companies trade allowances. The UK ETS does not accept offset credits for compliance. Offsets are only ever used for voluntary claims.

Why the market lost trust

Investigations in 2023 into the largest forest-protection credits found that most of them represented little or no real climate benefit, because the baselines of deforestation they were measured against had been overstated. Some well-known brands had built carbon neutral claims on those credits.

The result was a collapse in the price of cheap avoidance credits, a sharp rise in demand for verifiable removals, and new rules on claims. The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market now publishes Core Carbon Principles that set a quality floor, and credits carrying its label command a premium.

Five tests of a credible offset

Every serious standard applies some version of these five tests. If a credit you are offered cannot clearly pass all of them, the money is better spent on your own emissions.

1Additional

The project would not have happened without the money from selling credits. A forest that was going to be planted anyway, or a landfill gas capture that is legally required, does not remove any extra carbon.

2Measured, not modelled away

Removals are measured against a conservative baseline and verified by an independent body. Avoided-emission credits, which pay for something not to happen, are much harder to measure than removals and have been the source of most scandals.

3Permanent

Carbon stored in trees or soil can be released by fire, disease, felling or a change of owner. Good schemes hold back a buffer of credits as insurance and legally bind the land for decades.

4Not double counted

Each tonne should be retired in a public registry once, by one buyer, and not also claimed by the host country toward its national target. UK domestic codes avoid this problem because the removal and the buyer are in the same country.

5Does no harm

Monoculture plantations on productive farmland or peat soils, or projects that displace communities, are not credible even when the carbon maths works. Look for biodiversity and social co-benefits that are reported, not just promised.

The UK's own carbon codes

The UK has two domestic standards that are generally regarded as among the most rigorous anywhere, partly because the land, the registry, the verifier and the buyer are all under one legal system. They are also more expensive than international credits, which is a feature rather than a flaw.

Woodland Carbon Code

The UK government-backed standard for woodland creation, administered by Scottish Forestry across the whole UK. Projects are validated at planting and verified every five to ten years. Buyers receive Pending Issuance Units up front, which convert into Woodland Carbon Units once the carbon is verified as actually sequestered. Units are tracked on the UK Land Carbon Registry.

Peatland Code

Run by the IUCN UK Peatland Programme for restoring degraded peat bogs, which cover around 12% of the UK and emit carbon when drained or damaged. Restoration is counted as avoided emissions rather than removal, but is unusually well evidenced because the science of peat is mature and the land stays in UK jurisdiction.

Pending units versus verified units

A newly planted woodland has removed almost no carbon yet. Under the Woodland Carbon Code you buy Pending Issuance Units, a promise of future removal, and they only become Woodland Carbon Units when a verifier confirms the trees have grown. You can report Pending Units as a contribution to future removals, but you cannot use them to claim you have offset this year's emissions. Several high-profile claims have fallen foul of exactly this distinction.

What to do instead, or as well

Offsetting is not wrong in itself. The problem is using it in place of reduction, or using it to make claims it cannot support. The current consensus from standards bodies, regulators and investors converges on four principles.

Reduce first

The Science Based Targets initiative, which most large companies now follow, requires emissions to be cut by at least 90% before any credits are counted, and only for the residual 10%. Offsetting a footprint you have not tried to shrink is the definition of the problem.

Inset within your own supply chain

Insetting means funding reductions where your emissions actually arise: paying farmers in your supply chain to change practice, or financing a supplier's efficiency upgrade. It is harder to do than buying credits but it reduces your own Scope 3 rather than someone else's.

Buy removals, not avoidance

If you do buy credits, favour measured removals (afforestation with verified growth, peat restoration, engineered removals) over avoided-emission credits. Expect to pay more. A credible UK woodland unit costs many times what a bulk international avoidance credit does.

Say exactly what you did

The Competition and Markets Authority's Green Claims Code and the Advertising Standards Authority both expect substantiated, specific claims. 'We have bought verified credits equal to 20% of our 2025 emissions' is defensible. 'Carbon neutral' usually is not.

To know what you are offsetting you first need a measured footprint. Our guide to Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions explains how to build one, and the emissions calculator gives a quick starting estimate. For how offsetting fits into a credible transition plan, see net zero for UK businesses.

Official sources

Both UK codes publish their full standards, project lists and registries. Check a project there before buying from any intermediary.

Frequently asked questions

Can a business call itself carbon neutral by buying offsets?
Only with care. The Advertising Standards Authority and the Competition and Markets Authority Green Claims Code require that claims are accurate, substantiated and not misleading. A claim based entirely on cheap, unverified offsets with no reduction effort is likely to breach the code. Best practice is to reduce first, offset the residual with verified high-integrity credits, and state clearly what the claim covers.
What is the difference between a carbon credit and a carbon allowance?
A credit represents a tonne of CO2 removed or avoided by a project, sold on the voluntary market. An allowance, such as a UK Allowance under UK ETS, is a government permit to emit one tonne. UK ETS does not accept voluntary credits for compliance. They are separate systems with separate prices.
How much does it cost to offset a tonne of CO2 in the UK?
It varies enormously by quality. Cheap international avoidance credits can be a few pounds. UK Woodland Carbon Code units typically trade in the tens of pounds. Engineered removals such as direct air capture cost several hundred pounds per tonne. Price is a reasonable proxy for how likely the removal is to be real and permanent.
What is insetting?
Reducing or removing emissions within your own value chain rather than paying for a project elsewhere. A food manufacturer funding soil carbon practices on its supplier farms is insetting. It counts toward Scope 3 reductions rather than being bolted on as an offset.
Are carbon offsets tax deductible for UK businesses?
Generally yes, if purchased wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the trade, for example to meet a customer contract or a stated corporate commitment. Treatment of credits held as assets can be more complex. Confirm with your accountant.

Have a question we haven't covered? Get in touch or browse the carbon glossary.